Thursday, 10 November 2011

Pharmaceutical Production Scheduling

Day-to-day production scheduling in an international pharmaceutical company

Daily production scheduling can be fraught in any manufacturing environment. The inter-relationship between processes and resource conflicts in many pharmaceutical operations makes the task especially demanding. In this case study we learn how one of the world’s largest pharmaceutical companies is using Orchestrate each day in a production facility producing vaccines and self-injected prescription medicines.

The process - a study in complexity
Biopharmaceutical vaccine production is characterised by complex processes involving a large number of intermediate solutions. In this instance, there is an added dimension of multiple trains operating simultaneously, many of which share resources. Multiple stages and multiple products vying for the same space in the manufacturing suite. It involves hundreds of discrete activities to be performed, solutions to be made and cleans to be carried out on bioreactors, columns and filtration systems, all in a 24/7 environment that involves 200 people. The manufacturing plant is hard piped, so everything has to be finely synchronised to work optimally.

From spreadsheets…

The ubiquitous ‘morning production meeting’ had previously been dominated by Excel spreadsheets prepared and maintained by four full time planners for one product set and a further three for the second. Each had an intimate knowledge of specific parts of the production process, involving many hundreds of discrete solutions and activities. Because of the complexity, the rolling plan could cover only a week ahead, updated daily to accommodate all the unforeseen events that had happened in the previous 24 hours. The process was laborious, taking a whole morning each day, the separate plans lacked detail and engineering had to be planned informally between planners and engineers. It was not uncommon for electrical engineers, mechanical engineers and equipment to turn up for planned maintenance, only to learn that the schedule had changed and production was in process.

… to automation and full visibility
Having installed Orchestrate production scheduling software, the company reports that the process is so much smoother and more effective. Using fewer schedulers, the daily rolling plan now covers a four week period, rather than one, and takes only an hour to complete, instead of a morning.
A company director comments: “Particularly important, communications have been revolutionised. Everyone in the facility has access to the plan from shift managers and supervisors to shift engineers and engineering planners.  Giant touch-screen smart boards are sited on the floor and user screens provide access around the plant. A real-time ‘single version of the truth’ available to everyone, in an environment where processes take place in multiple rooms. A major benefit from improved communications has been significantly smoother shift changeovers.”
A senior planner describes the improvements to engineering planning: “Where maintenance had previously been performed as an ‘add on’, it is now fully integrated. Maintenance activities determined within our SAP system are now fed into Orchestrate, which schedules (and more importantly re-schedules in light of unplanned changes) maintenance tasks into non-production slots. The same is true for calibration of equipment and unplanned requests for downtime. Everyone informed.”
Implementation was smooth too. Recognising that most people are resistant to change, the Orchestrate production scheduling plan is displayed in much the same way as the old Excel spreadsheets, except it is now possible to burrow down into detail. A six week parallel run was planned to accommodate the change from old to new but, in practice, reactions from users were so positive, the parallel run was dropped after just a few days.
Last word comes from the plant director responsible for vaccine production: “For me, visibility is the biggest single win; everyone having access, whatever level of detail they need. That alone fully justifies the system.”

Pharmaceutical Capacity Planning

Major international pharmaceutical company uses Orchestrate production scheduling software to drive strategic initiatives

A number of pharmaceutical companies who use Orchestrate as their day-to-day production scheduling and capacity planning tool are also exploiting its functionality to address key strategic issues. In this case study, we visit a plant belonging to one of the world’s largest pharmaceutical companies, where Orchestrate has been employed in two major initiatives. The first, to boost productivity, significantly increasing capacity for the years ahead while using existing facilities. The second initiative is using Orchestrate’s modelling capabilities in a multi-million project to rationalise production, moving plant from one continent to another to create a ‘greenfield’ site.

Boosting capacity
The production team responsible for a group of self-medicating products within the plant were faced with the challenge of increasing manufacturing productivity. Orchestrate production scheduling software proved to be an ideal tool because, in its day-to-day scheduling role it had automated and build-in all the deep practical expertise of schedulers who understand  the plant, the way product moves through it, and the complex conflicts that exist with shared equipment and sequencing.
A company director explains: “Having put all the process basics into Orchestrate and having enhanced it, with help from Production Modelling, we were able to extend it to become a modelling tool capable of exploring ways to optimise the use of the facility. We were able to identify bottlenecks, to plug in fixes and build ‘what if’ scenarios in a true modelling sense. We then embarked on carefully chosen projects in which we already felt a high level of confidence using orchestrate in a day-to-day scheduling role. We knew they would work.”
“We have just completed a twelve month programme, removing bottlenecks and optimising the plant and have achieved a 20% faster throughput. We are now going into 2012 with higher capacity using exactly the same resources. That would have been impossible using traditional spreadsheet-type planning and scheduling tools.”

Manufacturing rationalisation
Like so many pharmaceutical companies, this multination is seeking to consolidate manufacturing into a smaller number of plants. The vaccine in question has a number of sub-types, currently manufactured within different sites in different continents.  The plan is to concentrate production within one site.
It has not been possible to accommodate the sub-types within existing facilities, which has meant completely rebuilding and recommissioning an existing suite, resulting in two separate suites.
The company has used Orchestrate to secure an understanding of how things will look day-to-day in terms of activities and in terms of resourcing. A future snapshot, as well as resource and capacity planning.
They have been able to model requirements for the next 5 years, as well as visualising the mix of products to arrive at a realistic plan of action.

The director responsible has extensive experience of such projects and comments: “Traditionally, spreadsheets such as Excel have been used to plan such activities, typically using a common server to provide an element of shared functionality. The difficulty with such an approach is that it is limited essentially to a chart comprising coloured squares.”
“Orchestrate has provided a wealth of information behind that. It’s possible to drill down to hours, minutes, seconds, rather than being restricted to crude day or half day blocks. Equally important, we have been able to apply ‘what if’ scenarios, particularly around capacity-related numbers. It is in the nature of forecasting that the further you move into the future, the less valid the numbers become. With Orchestrate, we have been able to look at what the forecasters have been saying, and then apply a range of variations. Using spreadsheets it would take days to accommodate secondary or parallel processes, figuring what a schedule might look like, while another team is separately figuring our recruitment needs – everyone speculating from their own spreadsheets. Orchestrate has given us the clarity of vision we need.”

Conclusion
The company has been able to use Orchestrate’s modelling capabilities in two projects, each with multi million dollar implications.  All that from the same easy to use software they are using for their daily scheduling”.

Call us now to find out how Orchestrate production scheduling software could help your operation.

Wednesday, 19 October 2011

Why Schedule?

“Why schedule?” might seem a facile question in a manufacturing environment. After all, every manufacturer, to a greater or lesser degree, has to plan and schedule production. In fact, most simply scratch the surface.
For most, their MRP or production systems simply do not provide the level of detail they need to manage right down to their own process complexities. No account is taken of current available capacity or constraints. That’s why most companies end up ‘cooking their own soup’.  Over-stressed planners end up spending too much time working with Excel spreadsheets, flowcharts and manual work-arounds.
Even the simplest finished product can go through complex stages that compete for resources, stages that are time and sequence dependent. And every planner has to cope with the unexpected - machine breakdowns, bottlenecks, rework, rush orders, and key personnel not being available.

That’s why smart production scheduling software – used for day-to-day scheduling, capacity planning and ‘what if’ analysis – can deliver such remarkable results.

The short answer to “Why schedule” is that rather than having to invest in new plant, modern scheduling software helps manufacturers get more out of existing facilities.

Longer term it helps companies rationalise manufacturing. And as a bonus, it also reduces errors and increases the productivity of planning staff.

Let’s see how…

Production scheduling in the real world

Intelligent scheduling systems reflect the real world. Real world constraints such as machine availability, people, their skills, tool changes, technical support, colour sequencing and sterile hold times.
They recognise how batches mesh together, how products can take alternative routes in the production process and how multiple products can use the same facility. Here are some examples:

Sequencing

We will start with the batch footprint. At its simplest, a batch footprint is little more than a list of consecutive processes, often portrayed on planning charts as ‘floating chimneys’.

Floating Chimneys

Modern production scheduling software goes much further. It can recognise that, for a single batch, the tasks have to occur on the same equipment. This is important because in a scheduling problem we need to view more than a single batch. We need to see how the batches mesh together.

What’s more, modern systems can manage multiple products in the same facility - different products, with a different batch footprint and a different choice of alternatives for routing. Real world.
And they can schedule all resources at the same time. Unlike most project management tools, intelligent production scheduling systems tell us what resources we need for each task and when they are needed. No conflicts.

Being able to manage complex sequencing, reducing the number of setups and making changes as circumstances dictate, all adds up to a significant improvement in plant and resource utilization.

Improved visibility

Effective production scheduling software can provide real visibility, across any number of planners and managers. Some systems can also integrate easily with existing ERP and planning systems, which means that planners are able to pick up feedback from execution systems with a live view of the production.
Such feedback alone can be sufficient justification for moving from Excel-type models to production scheduling systems. And KPIs can be built-in to ensure that whenever live decisions are made, any adverse ramifications are flagged up.

By defining views that are user-specific, smart scheduling systems can highlight different areas of the plan to different people. Views that automatically, when integrated with execution systems, keep pace with real time and highlight tasks that have been started, completed and so on.
Visibility of customer orders is a major tool that allows planners to improve on-time-in-full deliveries. And once companies feel more confident with the reliability of their planning data, it quickly becomes possible to improve lead times and cut WIP.

As an example, Cope Allman Jaycare users of our own Orchestrate production scheduling software have reported a reduction in WIP of 25% and a reduction in lead times of around 30%. Wastage has been cut significantly, simply because they now have fewer tool changes.

Customer Orders

Taking the long view

Production scheduling systems can often be used to enhance longer term Capacity Planning, or Sales & Operations Planning – an area traditionally plagued with unrealistic and over confident plans.

The level of detail and deep understanding of specific production processes possible within smart scheduling systems makes ‘What if?’ scenario planning a reality.

Boosting planner productivity

Finally, breaking free from time consuming, inflexible and error-prone Excel-type scheduling, boosts planner productivity.

In the words of one of our own customers, Steve Brownlee, IT Director, Verna Group: “What used to take a whole day for a planner can now be accomplished in twenty minutes. That doesn’t just mean eliminating the hassle; it means we can afford to run alternative scenarios, knowing that built-in KPI alerts will keep us on track. All that from a system that cost one third the cost of competitive systems. A system implemented in just six weeks and getting absolute benefits.” 

Conclusion

ERP and production execution systems offer very real advantages to manufacturing companies. However, when it comes to complex scheduling – and even simple finished products can involve complex interactions, routings and resource constraints - they are too generic.

They cannot take cognizance of the each company’s very specialized interactions between operations and resource constraints. And they often fall at the first hurdle, unable to cope with infinite capacity planning.
In the real world, there is no finite capacity of machines, tooling, materials, labour or other resources. And in the real world, change is the only constant.

Advanced planning and scheduling software eliminates most of the hassle associated with semi-manual planning systems. It is responsive to change and is nimble enough to provide alternatives whenever unplanned constrains occur – always with a close eye on KPIs. That is why it is so valuable, squeezing the most out of existing resources. Improving operational performance as well as planner performance.
Visibility of customer orders allows planners to improve OTIF deliveries. And once companies feel more confident with the reliability of their scheduling, it quickly becomes possible to improve lead times and cut WIP.

Friday, 23 September 2011

Orchestrate boosts efficiencies and drives down WIP at Cope Allman Jaycare

Simple products often have to go through complicated manufacturing sequences. This is particularly true for Cope Allman Jaycare, Europe’s largest injection blow moulding experts.

When the company decided to adopt Orchestrate, from Production Modelling, to automate their production scheduling, they set themselves some ambitious objectives – all of which have been met. In the system’s first twelve months, Work in Progress has been cut by 25 per cent, On-Time-In-Full (OTIF) delivery performance improved, the number of tool changes has been reduced and materials wastage cut. All this with a smaller planning headcount that has managed to significantly improve customer lead-times.

Cope Allman Jaycare are global specialists in the design and manufacturing of rigid plastic packaging and are market leaders in the Pharmaceutical and Healthcare sectors. Their pharmaceutical packaging includes containers for prescription only and over the counter medications while, in the medical sector, products include specialist packaging for infection control, diagnostics, hospital supplies, medical devices and so on. A vast range with very different characteristics, colour ranges and configurations. To complicate the process further, many products have to conform to strict regulatory requirements.

Despite being the supplier of choice for many blue chip companies, Cope Allman Jaycare cannot rest on their laurels. Their customers demand a high quality product, good service and competitive pricing. With these points in mind, Cope Allman Jaycare looked to Orchestrate to help them make improvements to their production scheduling that would drive down the cost of manufacture.

Phamaceutical  Stock 


The Challenge - Scheduling resources to maximise efficiency and cut wastage

The company employs a J D Edwards ERP solution for their computing needs but, like so many ERP users, found that comprehensive though they may be, they simply cannot cope with highly detailed scheduling requirements. For example, before adopting Orchestrate production scheduling software, planners had used spreadsheets to balance constraints when bringing together resources such as moulding tools, technical support for tool changes and ancillary equipment such as heaters. To reduce clean-down time, they had to accommodate colour sequence, from light to dark, and they had to consolidate different products to minimise tool changes and material wastage. Cap moulding had to be planned in line with the manufacture of containers and subsequent on-body printing, ready for cap mounting and the insertion of wadding.

There had to be a better way to schedule resources, so the company researched the market for a production scheduling software solution that would integrate easily with their other systems.

Injection Moulding  Injection Moulding

The Solution

“After researching the market and visiting users of different software solutions, we selected Orchestrate because it ticked all the boxes,” says Peter Teague, IT Director. “In particular, Orchestrate was the only solution that would support multiple planners in multiple locations. We have factories and planners in both Newcastle and Portsmouth and we wanted our planners, each looking after their own set of machines, to be able to use the system at the same time. Just as importantly, the people at Production Modelling impressed us with their understanding of how we worked and what we wanted to achieve.

Master data, such as product information, bill of materials, production routes and stock are all maintained within the JDE system. Orchestrate maintains the more detailed information required for scheduling, such as optimal colour sequencing and tooling information. Customer orders are input to JDE and then transferred automatically into Orchestrate for the more complex planning processes, with works orders automatically fed back to JDE. Both systems working seamlessly together eliminates unnecessary data entry and associated transcription errors. Orchestrate production scheduling software makes it a simple process that results in better sequencing and productivity increases.

According to Peter, the first year’s results were remarkable: “Three of our key performance objectives were to reduce work in progress, cut lead times and reduce wastage. Because we have so much more confidence in our scheduling, we don’t have to run so far ahead with production, which has resulted in a 25% reduction in WIP. Customers are delighted because lead times have now been cut from 6-8 week down to 4-6 weeks; much nearer the four week level and still improving. Wastage has been cut significantly simply because we now have fewer tool changes.”

“Other benefits include improved productivity from our packers, something in the order of 5%, which is quite significant. Our OTIF performance has improved from 92% to 97%. The important thing is, these are all quantifiable benefits.”

“We have also gained from less quantifiable improvements. As well as reducing planning headcount, they now have more time to take on extra responsibilities, such as procurement planning. Communications, both internally and externally have improved. The tool room can see schedules for themselves and can contribute directly – online self service. Being able to make changes directly into Orchestrate production scheduling software means fewer meetings. And pegging orders to purchase orders means we have been able to move more suppliers onto a Kanban approach, where they hold stocks for us and we call off on a daily basis. As to customer communications, we can make much better ‘available to promise’ commitments.”

Peter is confidently expecting more benefits from the system over the next twelve months, particularly in budgeting, partly by using ‘what if’ scenarios. Key Performance Indicators will also begin to play a more prominent role in planning and scheduling, which will help planners to recognise immediately the implications of any planning decision.

Last word from Peter: “ A great system and a marvelous group of people to work with. They really do understand our processes and are keen to help us find new ways to squeeze more out of the system.”

Thursday, 25 August 2011

Free Scheduling Software

Production Modelling are proud to release the full version of Orchestrate (Standard) free production scheduling software for 14 days!

Simply complete the online form and you will be able to download the full working version of Orchestrate Standard free production scheduling software. You will then be emailed a license code activating the scheduling software for 14 days, free of charge!

Included within the installation is a ‘Demo_Manufacturing’ database that shows you how simple it can be to plan orders on the Gantt chart. A new Webinar has also been created demonstrating how to build the model in under 30 minutes.

Orchestrate (Standard) scheduling software allows you to create, import and store databases on your computer with multiple logins for different users. It’s simple, intuitive Gantt chart enables you to plan orders in seconds and communicate what needs to be done when and on what resource.

Orchestrate (Standard) scheduling software has a multitude of functionality that can be turned on or off as required, making it simple for you to focus on the real complexities within your business.

Alternatively, Production Modelling can demonstrate our free production scheduling software via a live WebEx.
Production Modelling are keen to hear from you and answer any questions you may have. Please contact us  to speak with one of our team.

Wednesday, 3 August 2011

Scheduling Software goes live in just six weeks!

Orchestrate Scheduling Software goes live in just six weeks – boosting planning performance at Vernagroup

Vernagroup is a remarkable Bolton-based company that has a mission to be global leaders in providing premier medical pulp products, macerators and complementary products and services to healthcare markets around the world. Their advanced manufacturing processes are key to delivering the most cost effective products to a demanding market sector in all five continents. Orchestrate has transformed the management and control of production - a painless implementation in record time.



There must be a better way of doing things!
“What used to take a whole day for a planner can now be accomplished in twenty minutes. That doesn’t just mean eliminating the hassle, it means we can afford to run alternative scenarios, knowing that built-in KPI alerts will keep us on track.”

Steve Brownlee, IT Director, Vernagroup

“Our production facilities are state-of-the-art for our industry, with patented innovative technology and robotics,” says Steve Brownlee, IT Director, Vernagroup. “Yet our planning systems were cumbersome and unwieldy, relying heavily on spreadsheets and burning a lot of midnight oil. There had to be a better way of doing things, so we decided to computerize the process. Our selection criteria were clear: a proven ‘out of the box’ system that is cost effective, easy to implement, easy to use, and not requiring lots of IT support.”

The project team looked at more than one solution and selected Production Modelling’s Orchestrate scheduling software. “We liked the fact that it was a modern system so, unlike its competitors, it is very intuitive in use,” Steve explains. “It’s also very ‘visual’, very well presented, which makes it so much easier to assess different planning scenarios.”

To reassure themselves, the team visited Steelite, another successful manufacturing company with similar production complexities. The management at Steelite were able to demonstrate that Orchestrate offered the benefits of a packaged solution that could quickly be customized – very cost effectively.

“One third the cost, implemented in six weeks and getting absolute benefits”

"It has been somewhat staggering,” Steve comments, “the capability of the software to deal with our complexity, and also how rapidly the team from Production Modelling could configure the system to match our environment. Most systems in this arena are tricky to use and hard to set up. Orchestrate took just a couple of days to learn. The team from Production Modelling got to grips with our processes – from raw materials to finished product -within days, and were able to demonstrate a ‘first draft’ system configured to our production processes within two weeks. After our critique, they came back with the finished product.”

“We have gone from signing off a purchase order to delivering a fully functional solution that delivers absolute benefits in only six weeks!"

“... and that in a situation where we have spent around one third of the cost of the nearest rival solution.”



So, what are the benefits?

Steve describes the benefits: “We use Orchestrate for both strategic and day-to-day capacity planning. Looking two, three, four years ahead, we can assess capacity, any potential restrictions, storage requirements and any demand for additional production capability. At a detailed level, we are able to plan weekly and day-to-day production to meet sales forecasts and to maintain appropriate stock levels to service NHS and other customers. Our products are crucial to the effective running of hospital or private care facilities.”

“What used to take a whole day for a planner can now be accomplished in twenty minutes. That doesn’t just mean eliminating the hassle, it means we can afford to run alternative scenarios, knowing that built-in KPI alerts will keep us on track.”

“Specific products have to be dedicated to certain production lines, while other lines can accommodate mixed products. Add to that the need to minimize the changing of tool heads and you can begin to appreciate the complexity. Orchestrate scheduling software allows us to manage and police which products run on which lines and for how long, maximizing efficiency and throughput.”

“The system also takes into account planned downtime for regular servicing. Our aggressive growth plan mean we will shortly are looking to increase our operations. Our strategic planning shows us how well Orchestrate will be able to accommodate that.”

Last word from Steve: “It has been a painless experience and I can be confident that the users really are self sufficient. Orchestrate will never be a drain on IT resources. It has also been refreshing to work with such a focused supplier. People who are very passionate about their solutions and who can also be pragmatic. When they say they will deliver – they really do.”

Monday, 25 July 2011

Why Use Simulation Software

We at Production Modelling are often asked "How can I best run the factory to achieve my business objectives yet at the same time, meet customer demands?" Manufacturers are continually being asked to increase production volumes in less time with less people and for less money. Trying new ideas out in the factory are all very well, but they can take time, be disruptive, very costly, and you may not get it right first time. Today’s managers can’t afford to take such risks when implementing change.

Experimenting with new ideas on a computer model before you make changes for real is simple common sense. It takes the risk out of change. This is where simulation software users have gained a competitive edge, an advantage that results in bottom-line benefits to their business.


Why not flowcharts or process mapping?

Many organisations use static modelling tools, such as flowcharts, process mapping, and spreadsheets. Flowcharts and process mapping tools have their place, but on their own, they merely show relationships between processes and generally don’t provide any quantitive performance measures.


Why not spreadsheets?

 Spreadsheets are very useful, and do have their place, but also have serious limitations.

  • They are static models. This means that they cannot represent changes that occur with respect to time.
  • They are deterministic – using constant values, approximations or averages rather than the variability that exists in real life.
  • They can’t represent interdependencies. In other words, process steps are independent of each other. Again, a serious deficiency, as this limits the validity of the models.

At best, spreadsheets can give misleading results, and in many cases wildly inaccurate predictions. At worst, business decisions can be made on entirely inaccurate information. It’s no surprise that companies often wonder why the results from their spreadsheet models don’t match reality.


Here’s a simple illustration to prove why simulation is so important:


Picture a small cell where parts arrive on average every 30 seconds, queue for Machine1 or Machine 2, each of which takes on average of 1 minute to process

A spreadsheet model of this would show no queuing, 100% utilisation of the workstations, and average lead-time of 1 minute. In other words, a nicely balanced system.

Look what happens if we use variability. A normal, (bell-shaped), distribution of the same averages would be a more realistic way of representing the variability that exists in the real world.



Using a simulation model, running the process for just 8 hours, the results show a completely different (but more accurate) story. The machine utilisation is less than 100%, there are up to 13 jobs queuing for the machines, and the average lead time is over 5 minutes!!!


Imagine the difference in a more complex process, or if the process runs for a week or a month.

Click here to request a copy of this Model.


Why use Simulation Software?

This is why simulation software is so important. Simulation, and only simulation, takes into account the combined effect of variability, uncertainty, and complex interdependencies between processes
Production Modelling's simulation software is helping companies improve their businesses and become more competitive. Increasingly competitive markets bring new challenges and customers' demands are constantly changing. As a result, manufacturers need to become more responsive, more quickly, more efficiently, yet often within tighter budgets and timescales.

Production Modelling's simulation software is helping them to visualize, analyse and optimise their processes to achieve these business performance improvements.

Furthermore, simulation software is often used to help “sell” ideas to others to gain their commitment to change and show why one method will work better than another. The visual accuracy and animation of the model can provide a powerful communications tool. It can help speed up decisions affecting changes in the factory, and get people from the shop floor through to senior management all committed to the same ideas.